When Everything is Gaslighting, Nothing Is
How a word meant to expose manipulation became a way to dismiss it
I approached my first therapy appointment with two pages of notes in a fresh coil-bound journal, with the self-deprecating title, “Ways I am crazy.” It was mostly a list of traumas mixed with post-traumatic aversions, but one line stood apart from the rest:
“I doubt my own memories.”
This doubt was an asterisk behind every story I held, every connection I might make between experience and my own psychology. It clouded every insight that might have breathed room into the tightly wound capsule of my memories, pain, and the depression and anxiety I fought to keep from pulling me under. I was a young therapist, filled with theories and treatment approaches and insight into others’ struggles, but that niggling doubt kept me locked up, uncertain if I deserved my own healing. Doubting – and delaying – my own place on the couch of a therapy room.
I didn’t have words for it then, but this self-doubt is the direct outcome of experiencing chronic and insidious gaslighting – a phenomenon I would come to understand only years later. I researched and wrote a book about this then-little-discussed form of control, manipulation, and emotional abuse in 2020, published in 2021. By 2022, gaslighting was named the “Word of the Year” by Merriam-Webster. By 2025, my book was available for sale in eight languages and multiple editions around the world, and the word itself had become almost impossible to escape.
And yet, in the short years that have followed, gaslighting went from an obscure concept to an abused one, losing its liberating power almost as quickly as it arose through overuse and misuse.
I wrote Gaslighting to help break the barriers that once held me back from healing, to free others to trust their remembered stories so that they, too, could move toward healing.
I’m writing this today to remind us what gaslighting is – and crucially, what it is not – so that therapy-speak does not destroy the power of language to define, clarify, and liberate us from past experience.
Sometimes understanding a concept means understanding first what it is not.
Gaslighting is not simply being contradicted or having your stories challenged. People can disagree, question, or correct without it representing insidious psychological manipulation and intent to damage your self-confidence or mental health.
Gaslighting is not mere denial or lying when on defense by a person in a position of less power. If a child denies that they have homework or fabricates excuses for not doing their chores to avoid punishment, they are acting from avoidance or fear, not an attempt to control or make you feel crazy.
Gaslighting is not someone remembering events differently. This is a normal human phenomenon, as memory is the imperfect process of mentally recreating past events from varied perspectives. People can have different experiences of the same event without intent to harm.
True gaslighting is a manipulative pattern of psychological control that undermines your confidence in your own senses, memory, and intuition. This shifts power to the gaslighter, enabling them to gain control over you. Gaslighting typically comes from a position of power or desire to gain or maintain dominance.
Nevertheless, gaslighting can look like any of these things. A parent may gaslight to avoid accountability for abuse, which allows them to maintain control. If you buy into their narrative that they were good parents and you imagined the abuse, you won’t seek help, won’t draw attention, won’t challenge the abuse and change the dynamic. Instead, you question your own mind and take on the added psychological burden of believing you are crazy. A cheating partner may gaslight when evidence of their infidelity comes to light, not simply because they are afraid, but to maintain control of you and the benefits of keeping both partners. If you accept that your reaction is ‘psychotic jealousy’ rather than a righteous rage at betrayal, the partner maintains power.
And of course gaslighting will look like remembering things differently – your recollections are being directly challenged. The question to watch for is how others respond to disagreement. Is there grace in conversation to make room for the possibility that they are wrong? (And do you offer the same?) Is there a sense of negotiation or puzzling together of differing perspectives, or trying to make sense of how perspectives came to differ, rather than flat denial of your memory?
Willingness to consider alternative perspectives is a useful indicator of healthy disagreement, but an unwillingness to do so is not, by itself, proof of gaslighting. People may be emotionally immature, rigid, or simply very certain of their perspective without this inflexibility necessarily indicating gaslighting. Sometimes we are, in fact, mistaken. Openness to disagreement is a clue, not a diagnostic test.
Ordinary disagreement might sound like, “I don’t remember saying that. What I remember from our conversation is…”
A gaslighting pattern, on the other hand, will sound more like, “I never said that. You’re crazy. You’re always imagining things to make yourself the victim.”
Do you see the difference? The first person disagreeing focuses on what they remember. The second speaker focuses on what’s happening inside another person’s mind, adding judgment and insinuation. This may happen more subtly in a skilled manipulator, but the pattern is the same: a focus on undermining you, rather than pursuing understanding.
The danger inherent in overuse of the word “gaslighting” is that we end up right where we started. Where once we had no language for the confusing and maddening experience of having our memory and experiences systematically undermined, now we risk returning to a place of disempowerment and inability to accurately name a deeply disturbing and consequential form of emotional abuse. When everything is gaslighting, nothing is.
In my book, I outline seven steps to healing from gaslighting. The first step is recognizing the pattern and accurately naming it. But if saying “this is gaslighting” is met with a dismissive, “everything’s supposedly gaslighting these days,” those motivated to keep us small are emboldened to gaslight gaslighting awareness itself.
On a recent podcast interview with Breaking Taboo, I was asked the important question: Who benefits when we stop trusting ourselves? But today, I’m considering a related question: Who benefits when we lose the ability to name the phenomenon at all?
As a teen and young adult, I spent years doubting myself, bearing the psychological weight of all I’d endured while that fog of confusion misdirected me from the healing I needed. Finding the language to name and understand how that doubt came to be empowered me to grow.
We cannot afford to lose that language again.
for more essays by Dr Deborah Vinall, follow Mental Health Musings at dvinall.substack.com